Do killing animals promote life?

If you like this essay, share it with others

“Conservation theater” is the dubious practice of killing predators in the name of conservation


Many of us who wait in airport security lines have serious doubts about the effectiveness, the benefit, and the actual protection offered by the invasive procedures that we are required to endure. Our doubts become amplified when we read that dangerous and illegal items are regularly smuggled past the inspectors during government sanctioned tests. We have come to call this whole process “security theater” . It is all just a big show without any benefit or protection forthcoming.


The same can be said about the activities of many conservation workers who, while well meaning, don’t really conserve anything. Dr. Phillip A. Loring  calls it “conservation theater”. Specifically he is speaking of the killing of predators in the name of conservation while the true culprit is mankind’s activities of habitat fragmentation. He says that “killing is a crude tool for orchestrating conservation theater“.


Much of conservation theater practices are based on human beings setting quotas. Many conservation practitioners perform calculations as they attempt to define expected results that should be forthcoming from some action. Hunting quotas are a common example. By some magic, our practitioners are able to compute how many elk need to be killed to maintain some defined ecological balance. Yet, for the last 20 years, systems science has shown that the actions of Nature’s ecosystems (which are complex systems driven the many interactions of many chaotic inter-dependencies ) cannot be predicted by mankind. There is no such thing as equilibrium or steady state in Nature. Yet our conservation practitioners incorporate reference points and targets that are based on human fabricated goals of equilibrium and steady state.


Mankind’s conservation theater is sometimes based on the idea of trying to prevent changes in Nature – an impossible task. But, the truth is that no ecosystem  will exist unchanged over time. With or without mankind, change is normal in Nature. In the world of ecology, the only constant is change.


The surprising thing is that, while mankind cannot control Nature or manipulate a steady state, Nature has demonstrated her ability to come to her own equilibrium without the help of mankind. In fact, conservation theater and the meddling of mankind has often prevented Nature from achieving Her own equilibrium. A famous example of this important point is the Yellowstone wolves. In the early 1900s, our conservation practitioners (who were driven by wolf haters) decided to allow the extirpation (a fancy word for ” killing off”) of the Yellowstone wolves. Over the following years, big, unpredictable, and detrimental  changes took place in the Yellowstone ecosystem due to this “conservation theater”.  Around 1990,  conservation practitioners relented and released wolves back into Yellowstone. The entire story is  dramatic proof that Nature can take care of herself without mankind’s conservation theater. In addition, as shown by the Yellowstone wolf story, conservation theater can be destructive. The drama is aptly described in a wonderful video entitled “Lords of Nature“.


In response to the fantasy of conservation theater, Dr. Loring  offers the following to us:


“I believe that if people are to develop new and transformative ways of living sustainably they need a metaphor that inspires not just restraint but creativity and innovation, a metaphor that casts people not as tragic destroyers but native and welcome participants in the natural order.”


Why Do I Write These Essays?

Nothing in Nature exists in isolation. The movement of life’s energy, which originates in the sun, takes place because everything is interconnected and interdependent. Your consciousness of interdependence in Nature means that, every time you engage Nature, you ask yourself how a creature, a plant, yourself, or a natural object is connected to another and to Nature’s greater scheme of things. With this awareness you are prepared to protect Nature’s environment that sustains you. And, you create your legacy by encouraging others to do likewise.


If, after reading my essays, you find yourself embracing these ideas, I am thrilled in knowing that I’ve played some small part in setting this world view in motion in your mind.


Please Comment and Subscribe

I invite you to subscribe to my newsletter using the sign-up form provided at the upper right corner of this web page. As a subscriber you will receive regular email announcements of new essays that I publish or popular essays that i have previously published. In these essays you will have the opportunity to share comments and ideas about a topic. Your security is important to me. Please know that your email address is never distributed to anyone.


You are strongly encouraged to become one of my 11,000+ followers on Twitter. My Twitter ID is @ballenamar . With Twitter, in addition to receiving daily Tweets that announce my essays, you will see when I retweet something that I read and that I think is important.


My name is Bill Graham. As a Marine Biologist who has worked in the US and Mexico for 30 years, I am a student of Nature, a teacher, a researcher, and a nature photographer. Through my work, I have acquired an ever growing passion for how everything in Nature is connected. Today, I travel extensively contemplating about, writing about, and photographing Nature’s connections. I also work with conservation projects in the USA and Mexico and mentor talented youth.

3 thoughts on “Do killing animals promote life?”

  1. We call ourselves wise man and and yet we can see what we’re doing to this beautiful planet – our one, and only, home and continue to rush head long into catastrophe. We need to think about how we live and choose to reduce our own population – not our fellow species.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.